The $1,000 Dare to Write an Encyclopedia on a Pinhead
Nanotechnology
On December 29, 1959, at the American Physical Society's annual meeting at Caltech, Richard Feynman gave a talk with a cheeky title: “There's Plenty of Room at the Bottom.” He spoke without notes, and we only have it because an admirer recorded it. Near the end he did something physicists rarely do in public. He put money on the table. “It is my intention,” he said, “to offer a prize of $1,000 to the first guy who can take the information on the page of a book and put it on an area 1/25,000 smaller in linear scale in such manner that it can be read by an electron microscope.” It took twenty-six years, and a graduate student who was three years old when the dare was made, to collect.
The talk was a tour of a world nobody could yet visit. Feynman asked why we could not write the entire Encyclopaedia Britannica on the head of a pin, then estimated that, stored in three dimensions, every book in the world could fit in a speck about a two-hundredth of an inch across. He floated the idea, credited to his friend Albert Hibbs, of “swallowing the doctor”: a tiny surgical robot you could gulp down like a pill. And he sketched a gloriously odd route there. Build mechanical hands a quarter of your size, use them to build smaller hands, and those to build smaller ones still, until perhaps a billion tiny factories work side by side. He warned that the rules would change on the way down: gravity stops mattering, while the faint stickiness between molecules known as van der Waals forces takes over, so every tool would need rethinking.
He offered a second prize too, for a working electric motor that would fit inside a cube a sixty-fourth of an inch on a side. By November 1960 a Caltech graduate named William McLellan had built one, using two and a half months of lunch hours, a microscope, a watchmaker's lathe and a toothpick. It met the rules exactly but advanced nothing; it was superb craftsmanship rather than new physics. Feynman had technically only announced an intention to offer a prize, but his conscience nagged and he paid anyway. Caltech's magazine reported his “worried thoughts” with mock sympathy: he had since married and bought a house and did not have another spare $1,000. Its appeal to anyone chasing the writing prize: “TAKE YOUR TIME! WORK SLOWLY! RELAX!”
The world obliged. The paper drifted around among enthusiasts for a quarter of a century, until a Stanford graduate student named Ken Polasko pointed it out to fellow student Tom Newman. Newman's doctoral research was on speeding up electron beam lithography, drawing patterns with a focused stream of electrons, and his system worked rather like a dot-matrix printer. He needed an arbitrary pattern to show it off. “Text is ideal,” he said, “because it has so many different shapes.” He picked the opening page of A Tale of Two Cities, a favourite novel with a famous first paragraph. With a beam about one five-millionth of an inch wide, he traced the words onto a thin plastic membrane, then dissolved the exposed regions away in ethanol. A good start over one weekend became a month of hard work to make the letters legible. Then came the strangest problem: finding the text at all. Compared with the writing, the little square of plastic was a vast empty desert, and it took Ann Marshall of Stanford's Center for Materials Research tuning her electron microscope to bring up a readable image.
Newman telegrammed Feynman to ask whether anyone had claimed the prize. Nobody had. The page measured about 5.9 by 5.9 micrometres, and Feynman's letter with the check is pure delight. Each dot, he calculated, was only about 60 atoms on a side, the whole page only ten wavelengths of light across. The entire Britannica at that scale would fit on less than two millimetres on a side, “the head of a small plain pin.” Newman passed his PhD oral exam that December 4, tiny Dickens and all.
Here is the twist. When the historian Chris Toumey traced the talk's influence in 2008, he found it was barely cited for its first twenty years, and several of the scientists who built the field said they had not read it until later. It was rediscovered only after the word “nanotechnology” caught fire in the late 1980s, after the scanning tunneling microscope arrived in 1981, and after researchers arranged 35 individual xenon atoms in 1990. Then it became scripture. In January 2000, President Clinton quoted Feynman's question about arranging atoms one by one while calling for a $500 million National Nanotechnology Initiative.
So was the talk a prophecy, or a story we told ourselves afterwards? Perhaps both. In 2016, researchers at TU Delft stored a paragraph of Feynman's own speech, 1,016 bytes of it, by positioning chlorine atoms on a copper surface, each bit marked by an atom and the gap beside it, at 502 terabits per square inch. The lecture had finally been written at the scale it described. The lesson is a lovely one: sometimes the most useful thing a scientist can do is not solve a problem but point at it, offer a modest reward, and tell everyone to take their time.